Justice Kennedy is not a judge, but head of the junta
Another example of why Justice Anthony Kennedy is in the wrong job — he thinks he’s a legislator, not a judge.
What’s the difference? That’s the problem — the differences get more blurred by the day, until the time comes when our legislators spend all of their time campaigning, voicing opinions, and avoiding decisions or votes on legislation (except that legislation that cedes power to other interests or organizations), and thereby avoiding responsibility, while our judges and justices fill the vacuum in areas where they have no reponsibility or accountability at all.
Justice Kennedy admitted as much today in his opinion outlawing the death penalty for child rape. When he said, ”there is a national consensus against capital punishment for the crime of child rape,” he is admitting that public opinion, and not the law or the Constitution, influenced his decision.
This is preposterous, arrogant, and dicatorial. No one (least of all judges) is qualified or authorized to base decisions on public opinion, even if they knew how. (Legislators think they know how, but they often fail, and lose elections, from which justices are immune.) Public opinion only counts when it expresses itself through democratic institutions and a legal framework. So if several states had abolished capital punishment for child rapists, why does Anthony Kennedy feel that it then becomes necessary for him to force the remaining states to follow along? Is that the job of the Supreme Court?
A dictator can be loved; he can have his pulse on the people’s will; he can even be right somtimes; but he’s still a dictator.
Anthony Kennedy is loved by academia and elite circles within the Beltway (including some conservatives such as George Will); he has his pulse on their opinions and values and apparently derives satisfaction from being stroked by the editorial pages of the Washington Post and NYT; and he has also stumbled on some correct rulings; but he is still a dictator in the sense that he shamlessly exercises power which is not rightfully or constitutionally his.
Maybe it’s time to start calling the five-justice majority headed by Kennedy as the “ruling junta.”


